Alaska Anchorage 3

16-3, 10-1 GNAC

MSU Billings 1

10-9, 5-6 GNAC

1st2nd3rd4thFinal
Alaska Anchorage232525253
MSU Billings251423231
October 18, 2014 at 7 PM
Billings, Mont.
Attendance: 265
Alaska AnchorageATTACKSETSERVEDEFBLOCKGEN
NOSTARTERSSPKETAPCTASASEREDIGBSBABEBHEPTS
12McGlathery,Kayla35315.1330000112007.0
13Pottle,Brooke47638.026122014110010.5
14Zanders,Katelynn413534.235003014010013.5
15Braun,Erin34211.1820010201004.5
2Hooe,Morgan44013.30842320803008.5
4Johnson,Sarah4011-1.0001011200000.0
NOSUBSTITUTESSPKETAPCTASASEREDIGBSBABEBHEPTS
1Barker,Quinn4000.00011021600001.0
6Mackey,Julia416631.323120312200020.0
8McInerney,Caitlin2114.0000000022004.0
TOTALS45024147.17746896696100069.0
Team Attack by SetKETAPCT
113427.333
28629.069
315743.186
414748.146
Total Team Blocks: 11.0
MSU BillingsATTACKSETSERVEDEFBLOCKGEN
NOSTARTERSSPKETAPCTASASEREDIGBSBABEBHEPTS
10Gentili,Alaina47219.2630001110008.0
14Kirk,Kimmy4000.00010041900000.0
16Norris,Krista49544.09101117110011.5
4Williams,Kyndal4115.00039030611002.5
5Walter,Chelsey412423.34801202120015.0
8Ward,Ashlynn49628.10700000300012.0
NOSUBSTITUTESSPKETAPCTASASEREDIGBSBABEBHEPTS
1Roderick,Mataia4000.00012121100002.0
13Grimsrud,Monica47730.0000010300007.0
3Findon,Kierney1000.0000010000000.0
7Wells,Haley4001.00022102000002.0
TOTALS44525150.13343610869740060.0
Team Attack by SetKETAPCT
117431.419
24929-.172
313644.159
411646.109
Total Team Blocks: 9.0
1st Set2nd Set3rd Set4th Set
Alaska Anchorage Score MSU Billings
Start of 1st Set
UAA starters: Pottle,Brooke; McGlathery,Kayla; Hooe,Morgan; Zanders,Katelynn; Braun,Erin; Johnson,Sarah; libero Barker,Quinn.
MSUB starters: Gentili,Alaina; Ward,Ashlynn; Norris,Krista; Williams,Kyndal; Walter,Chelsey; Kirk,Kimmy; libero Wells,Haley.
0-1[Wells,Haley] Attack error by Johnson,Sarah.
0-2[Wells,Haley] Attack error by McGlathery,Kayla.
[Wells,Haley] Kill by Hooe,Morgan.1-2
1-3[Pottle,Brooke] Kill by Ward,Ashlynn (from Williams,Kyndal).
MSUB subs: Roderick,Mataia; Ward,Ashlynn.
[Roderick,Mataia] Kill by Hooe,Morgan (from Barker,Quinn).2-3
UAA subs: Braun,Erin; McGlathery,Kayla.
2-4[Barker,Quinn] Kill by Norris,Krista (from Williams,Kyndal).
MSUB subs: Grimsrud,Monica; Kirk,Kimmy.
[Norris,Krista] Kill by Zanders,Katelynn (from Hooe,Morgan).3-4
UAA subs: Mackey,Julia; Johnson,Sarah.
[Hooe,Morgan] Attack error by Grimsrud,Monica.4-4
4-5[Hooe,Morgan] Kill by Walter,Chelsey (from Williams,Kyndal).
MSUB subs: Gentili,Alaina; Wells,Haley.
4-6[Walter,Chelsey] Kill by Gentili,Alaina (from Williams,Kyndal).
[Walter,Chelsey] Service error.5-6
MSUB subs: Wells,Haley; Walter,Chelsey.
5-7[Zanders,Katelynn] Attack error by Mackey,Julia.
5-8[Williams,Kyndal] Kill by Gentili,Alaina (from Williams,Kyndal).
[Williams,Kyndal] Service error.6-8
UAA subs: McGlathery,Kayla; Barker,Quinn.
[Braun,Erin] Kill by Mackey,Julia (from Hooe,Morgan).7-8
7-9[Braun,Erin] Kill by Gentili,Alaina (from Williams,Kyndal).
UAA subs: Barker,Quinn; Braun,Erin.
[Grimsrud,Monica] Kill by Mackey,Julia (from Hooe,Morgan).8-9
UAA subs: Johnson,Sarah; Mackey,Julia.
MSUB subs: Kirk,Kimmy; Grimsrud,Monica.
8-10[Johnson,Sarah] Kill by Ward,Ashlynn (from Williams,Kyndal).
MSUB subs: Walter,Chelsey; Gentili,Alaina.
8-11[Wells,Haley] Kill by Ward,Ashlynn (from Wells,Haley).
8-12[Wells,Haley] Service ace (Barker,Quinn).
[Wells,Haley] Kill by Pottle,Brooke (from Hooe,Morgan).9-12
[Pottle,Brooke] Service ace (Kirk,Kimmy).10-12
[Pottle,Brooke] Attack error by Ward,Ashlynn.11-12
11-13[Pottle,Brooke] Service error.
MSUB subs: Roderick,Mataia; Ward,Ashlynn.
11-14[Roderick,Mataia] Kill by Norris,Krista (from Williams,Kyndal).
[Roderick,Mataia] Kill by McGlathery,Kayla (from Hooe,Morgan).12-14
UAA subs: Braun,Erin; McGlathery,Kayla.
[Barker,Quinn] Kill by Braun,Erin.13-14
[Barker,Quinn] Kill by Zanders,Katelynn (from Hooe,Morgan).14-14
[Barker,Quinn] Kill by Zanders,Katelynn (from Hooe,Morgan).15-14
15-15[Barker,Quinn] Kill by Walter,Chelsey (from Williams,Kyndal).
MSUB subs: Grimsrud,Monica; Kirk,Kimmy.
15-16[Norris,Krista] Service ace (Johnson,Sarah).
[Norris,Krista] Kill by Zanders,Katelynn (from Hooe,Morgan).16-16
UAA subs: Mackey,Julia; Johnson,Sarah.
16-17[Hooe,Morgan] Kill by Grimsrud,Monica (from Williams,Kyndal).
MSUB subs: Gentili,Alaina; Wells,Haley.
[Walter,Chelsey] Service error.17-17
MSUB subs: Wells,Haley; Walter,Chelsey.
17-18[Zanders,Katelynn] Kill by Williams,Kyndal (from Roderick,Mataia).
MSUB subs: Ward,Ashlynn; Roderick,Mataia.
17-19[Williams,Kyndal] Kill by Ward,Ashlynn.
[Williams,Kyndal] Service error.18-19
UAA subs: McGlathery,Kayla; Barker,Quinn.
18-20[Braun,Erin] Kill by Grimsrud,Monica (from Williams,Kyndal).
18-21[Grimsrud,Monica] Attack error by Mackey,Julia.
[Grimsrud,Monica] Kill by Mackey,Julia (from Hooe,Morgan).19-21
UAA subs: Johnson,Sarah; Mackey,Julia.
MSUB subs: Kirk,Kimmy; Grimsrud,Monica.
19-22[Johnson,Sarah] Kill by Gentili,Alaina.
MSUB subs: Walter,Chelsey; Gentili,Alaina.
19-23[Wells,Haley] Service ace (Barker,Quinn).
[Wells,Haley] Attack error by Norris,Krista.20-23
[Pottle,Brooke] Bad set by Williams,Kyndal.21-23
[Pottle,Brooke] Attack error by Ward,Ashlynn.22-23
22-24[Pottle,Brooke] Kill by Walter,Chelsey (from Williams,Kyndal).
MSUB subs: Roderick,Mataia; Ward,Ashlynn.
[Roderick,Mataia] Kill by McGlathery,Kayla (from Hooe,Morgan).23-24
UAA subs: Braun,Erin; McGlathery,Kayla.
23-25[Barker,Quinn] Kill by Walter,Chelsey (from Williams,Kyndal).
1st Set2nd Set3rd Set4th Set
Alaska Anchorage Score MSU Billings
Start of 2nd Set
MSUB starters: Williams,Kyndal; Gentili,Alaina; Ward,Ashlynn; Norris,Krista; Walter,Chelsey; Kirk,Kimmy; libero Wells,Haley.
UAA starters: Pottle,Brooke; McGlathery,Kayla; Hooe,Morgan; Zanders,Katelynn; Braun,Erin; Johnson,Sarah; libero Barker,Quinn.
0-1[Johnson,Sarah] Kill by Walter,Chelsey (from Williams,Kyndal).
MSUB subs: Roderick,Mataia; Ward,Ashlynn.
[Roderick,Mataia] Attack error by Norris,Krista.1-1
1-2[Pottle,Brooke] Service error.
MSUB subs: Grimsrud,Monica; Kirk,Kimmy.
[Norris,Krista] Service error.2-2
UAA subs: Braun,Erin; McGlathery,Kayla.
[Barker,Quinn] Attack error by Grimsrud,Monica (block by Hooe,Morgan; Braun,Erin).3-2
3-3[Barker,Quinn] Attack error by Zanders,Katelynn.
MSUB subs: Gentili,Alaina; Wells,Haley.
MSUB subs: Findon,Kierney; Walter,Chelsey.
[Findon,Kierney] Service error.4-3
MSUB subs: Walter,Chelsey; Findon,Kierney.
[Hooe,Morgan] Service ace (Gentili,Alaina).5-3
[Hooe,Morgan] Service ace (Roderick,Mataia).6-3
[Hooe,Morgan] Attack error by Grimsrud,Monica.7-3
7-4[Hooe,Morgan] Service error.
MSUB subs: Ward,Ashlynn; Roderick,Mataia.
[Williams,Kyndal] Service error.8-4
8-5[Zanders,Katelynn] Kill by Grimsrud,Monica (from Williams,Kyndal).
[Grimsrud,Monica] Attack error by Gentili,Alaina.9-5
UAA subs: McGlathery,Kayla; Barker,Quinn.
MSUB subs: Kirk,Kimmy; Grimsrud,Monica.
[Braun,Erin] Kill by Mackey,Julia (from Hooe,Morgan).10-5
10-6[Braun,Erin] Service error.
MSUB subs: Walter,Chelsey; Gentili,Alaina.
UAA subs: Barker,Quinn; Braun,Erin.
10-7[Wells,Haley] Attack error by Pottle,Brooke (block by Walter,Chelsey).
[Wells,Haley] Kill by Mackey,Julia (from Hooe,Morgan).11-7
UAA subs: Johnson,Sarah; Mackey,Julia.
[Johnson,Sarah] Attack error by Walter,Chelsey.12-7
12-8[Johnson,Sarah] Attack error by Pottle,Brooke (block by Ward,Ashlynn).
MSUB subs: Roderick,Mataia; Ward,Ashlynn.
12-9[Roderick,Mataia] Attack error by McGlathery,Kayla.
[Roderick,Mataia] Kill by Hooe,Morgan (from Johnson,Sarah).13-9
[Pottle,Brooke] Kill by McGlathery,Kayla.14-9
[Pottle,Brooke] Service ace (Kirk,Kimmy).15-9
[Pottle,Brooke] Kill by Zanders,Katelynn (from Hooe,Morgan).16-9
16-10[Pottle,Brooke] Kill by Norris,Krista (from Williams,Kyndal).
MSUB subs: Grimsrud,Monica; Kirk,Kimmy.
[Norris,Krista] Attack error by Grimsrud,Monica (block by Hooe,Morgan; McGlathery,Kayla).17-10
[Barker,Quinn] Service ace (Norris,Krista).18-10
18-11[Barker,Quinn] Attack error by Zanders,Katelynn.
18-12[Walter,Chelsey] Kill by Grimsrud,Monica (from Williams,Kyndal).
[Walter,Chelsey] Bad set by Roderick,Mataia.19-12
UAA subs: Mackey,Julia; Johnson,Sarah.
MSUB subs: Roderick,Mataia; Walter,Chelsey.
[Hooe,Morgan] Attack error by Grimsrud,Monica (block by Mackey,Julia).20-12
20-13[Hooe,Morgan] Attack error by Mackey,Julia.
MSUB subs: Ward,Ashlynn; Roderick,Mataia.
[Williams,Kyndal] Kill by Mackey,Julia (from Hooe,Morgan).21-13
[Zanders,Katelynn] Attack error by Grimsrud,Monica.22-13
[Zanders,Katelynn] Kill by Pottle,Brooke (from Hooe,Morgan).23-13
23-14[Zanders,Katelynn] Service error.
[Grimsrud,Monica] Kill by Mackey,Julia (from Hooe,Morgan).24-14
MSUB subs: Kirk,Kimmy; Grimsrud,Monica.
UAA subs: McGlathery,Kayla; Barker,Quinn.
[Braun,Erin] Attack error by Ward,Ashlynn.25-14
1st Set2nd Set3rd Set4th Set
Alaska Anchorage Score MSU Billings
Start of 3rd Set
UAA starters: Mackey,Julia; Braun,Erin; Hooe,Morgan; Pottle,Brooke; Zanders,Katelynn; McInerney,Caitlin; libero Barker,Quinn.
MSUB starters: Walter,Chelsey; Williams,Kyndal; Norris,Krista; Gentili,Alaina; Kirk,Kimmy; Ward,Ashlynn; libero Wells,Haley.
[Wells,Haley] Service error.1-0
1-1[Pottle,Brooke] Kill by Ward,Ashlynn (from Williams,Kyndal).
MSUB subs: Roderick,Mataia; Ward,Ashlynn.
1-2[Roderick,Mataia] Service ace (Mackey,Julia).
1-3[Roderick,Mataia] Kill by Norris,Krista (from Wells,Haley).
[Roderick,Mataia] Attack error by Norris,Krista (block by McInerney,Caitlin; Hooe,Morgan).2-3
UAA subs: Braun,Erin; McInerney,Caitlin.
[Barker,Quinn] Bad set by Williams,Kyndal.3-3
3-4[Barker,Quinn] Attack error by Zanders,Katelynn.
MSUB subs: Grimsrud,Monica; Kirk,Kimmy.
3-5[Norris,Krista] Attack error by Zanders,Katelynn (block by Williams,Kyndal; Walter,Chelsey).
3-6[Norris,Krista] Attack error by Braun,Erin.
[Norris,Krista] Kill by Braun,Erin (from Hooe,Morgan).4-6
4-7[Hooe,Morgan] Kill by Grimsrud,Monica (from Williams,Kyndal).
MSUB subs: Gentili,Alaina; Wells,Haley.
4-8[Walter,Chelsey] Kill by Grimsrud,Monica (from Williams,Kyndal).
4-9[Walter,Chelsey] Attack error by Mackey,Julia.
[Walter,Chelsey] Kill by Zanders,Katelynn (from Hooe,Morgan).5-9
MSUB subs: Wells,Haley; Walter,Chelsey.
[Zanders,Katelynn] Kill by Mackey,Julia (from Hooe,Morgan).6-9
[Zanders,Katelynn] Kill by Pottle,Brooke (from Hooe,Morgan).7-9
[Zanders,Katelynn] Kill by Mackey,Julia (from Hooe,Morgan).8-9
[Zanders,Katelynn] Attack error by Grimsrud,Monica (block by Mackey,Julia).9-9
9-10[Zanders,Katelynn] Attack error by Braun,Erin.
MSUB subs: Ward,Ashlynn; Roderick,Mataia.
[Williams,Kyndal] Kill by Mackey,Julia (from Hooe,Morgan).10-10
UAA subs: Johnson,Sarah; Braun,Erin; McInerney,Caitlin; Barker,Quinn.
10-11[Johnson,Sarah] Kill by Gentili,Alaina (from Williams,Kyndal).
[Grimsrud,Monica] Kill by Mackey,Julia (from Hooe,Morgan).11-11
MSUB subs: Kirk,Kimmy; Grimsrud,Monica.
[Mackey,Julia] Kill by Braun,Erin.12-11
[Mackey,Julia] Kill by Pottle,Brooke (from Hooe,Morgan).13-11
13-12[Mackey,Julia] Kill by Ward,Ashlynn (from Williams,Kyndal).
MSUB subs: Walter,Chelsey; Gentili,Alaina.
[Wells,Haley] Attack error by Ward,Ashlynn (block by Pottle,Brooke; McInerney,Caitlin).14-12
[Pottle,Brooke] Attack error by Walter,Chelsey (block by McInerney,Caitlin).15-12
15-13[Pottle,Brooke] Kill by Walter,Chelsey (from Kirk,Kimmy).
MSUB subs: Roderick,Mataia; Ward,Ashlynn.
[Roderick,Mataia] Kill by Hooe,Morgan (from Pottle,Brooke).16-13
UAA subs: Braun,Erin; McInerney,Caitlin.
16-14[Barker,Quinn] Kill by Norris,Krista (from Williams,Kyndal).
MSUB subs: Grimsrud,Monica; Kirk,Kimmy.
[Norris,Krista] Kill by Braun,Erin (from Hooe,Morgan).17-14
[Hooe,Morgan] Kill by Mackey,Julia (from Hooe,Morgan).18-14
18-15[Hooe,Morgan] Service error.
MSUB subs: Gentili,Alaina; Wells,Haley.
[Walter,Chelsey] Attack error by Gentili,Alaina.19-15
19-16[Zanders,Katelynn] Service error.
MSUB subs: Wells,Haley; Walter,Chelsey; Ward,Ashlynn; Roderick,Mataia.
19-17[Williams,Kyndal] Attack error by Pottle,Brooke (block by Gentili,Alaina).
[Williams,Kyndal] Kill by Mackey,Julia (from Hooe,Morgan).20-17
UAA subs: Johnson,Sarah; Braun,Erin; McInerney,Caitlin; Barker,Quinn.
20-18[Johnson,Sarah] Kill by Norris,Krista (from Williams,Kyndal).
[Grimsrud,Monica] Service error.21-18
MSUB subs: Kirk,Kimmy; Grimsrud,Monica.
[Mackey,Julia] Attack error by Ward,Ashlynn.22-18
[Mackey,Julia] Service ace (Kirk,Kimmy).23-18
23-19[Mackey,Julia] Kill by Gentili,Alaina (from Williams,Kyndal).
MSUB subs: Walter,Chelsey; Gentili,Alaina.
23-20[Wells,Haley] Attack error by Pottle,Brooke (block by Ward,Ashlynn).
23-21[Wells,Haley] Kill by Norris,Krista (from Williams,Kyndal).
23-22[Wells,Haley] Kill by Ward,Ashlynn (from Williams,Kyndal).
[Wells,Haley] Kill by McInerney,Caitlin (from Hooe,Morgan).24-22
24-23[Pottle,Brooke] Kill by Walter,Chelsey (from Williams,Kyndal).
MSUB subs: Roderick,Mataia; Ward,Ashlynn.
[Roderick,Mataia] Kill by Zanders,Katelynn (from Hooe,Morgan).25-23
1st Set2nd Set3rd Set4th Set
Alaska Anchorage Score MSU Billings
Start of 4th Set
MSUB starters: Norris,Krista; Gentili,Alaina; Williams,Kyndal; Walter,Chelsey; Ward,Ashlynn; Kirk,Kimmy; libero Wells,Haley.
UAA starters: Mackey,Julia; Hooe,Morgan; Zanders,Katelynn; McGlathery,Kayla; McInerney,Caitlin; Pottle,Brooke; libero Barker,Quinn.
0-1[Mackey,Julia] Attack error by Pottle,Brooke (block by Ward,Ashlynn).
MSUB subs: Roderick,Mataia; Ward,Ashlynn.
[Roderick,Mataia] Service error.1-1
1-2[Pottle,Brooke] Kill by Norris,Krista (from Williams,Kyndal).
MSUB subs: Grimsrud,Monica; Kirk,Kimmy.
1-3[Norris,Krista] Bad set by Hooe,Morgan.
1-4[Norris,Krista] Attack error by Zanders,Katelynn (block by Williams,Kyndal).
[Norris,Krista] Kill by Zanders,Katelynn (from Hooe,Morgan).2-4
UAA subs: McInerney,Caitlin; McGlathery,Kayla.
2-5[Barker,Quinn] Kill by Walter,Chelsey (from Williams,Kyndal).
MSUB subs: Gentili,Alaina; Wells,Haley.
2-6[Walter,Chelsey] Service ace (Mackey,Julia).
[Walter,Chelsey] Kill by Zanders,Katelynn (from Hooe,Morgan).3-6
MSUB subs: Wells,Haley; Walter,Chelsey.
[Hooe,Morgan] Service ace (Roderick,Mataia).4-6
4-7[Hooe,Morgan] Attack error by McInerney,Caitlin.
MSUB subs: Ward,Ashlynn; Roderick,Mataia.
[Williams,Kyndal] Kill by Zanders,Katelynn (from Hooe,Morgan).5-7
5-8[Zanders,Katelynn] Service error.
6-9[Johnson,Sarah] Kill by Ward,Ashlynn (from Williams,Kyndal).
UAA subs: Barker,Quinn; Johnson,Sarah.
MSUB subs: Wells,Haley; Gentili,Alaina.
6-10[Wells,Haley] Attack error by Mackey,Julia (block by Norris,Krista).
6-11[Wells,Haley] Attack error by Mackey,Julia (block by Walter,Chelsey; Norris,Krista).
6-12[Wells,Haley] Attack error by McGlathery,Kayla.
[Wells,Haley] Kill by Mackey,Julia (from Hooe,Morgan).7-12
[Mackey,Julia] Kill by McGlathery,Kayla (from Hooe,Morgan).8-12
[Mackey,Julia] Attack error by Ward,Ashlynn (block by Pottle,Brooke).9-12
[Mackey,Julia] Service ace (Kirk,Kimmy).10-12
[Mackey,Julia] Attack error by Norris,Krista (block by McGlathery,Kayla).11-12
11-13[Mackey,Julia] Kill by Ward,Ashlynn (from Williams,Kyndal).
MSUB subs: Roderick,Mataia; Ward,Ashlynn.
11-14[Roderick,Mataia] Service ace (Mackey,Julia).
11-15[Roderick,Mataia] Kill by Walter,Chelsey (from Williams,Kyndal).
[Roderick,Mataia] Kill by Pottle,Brooke (from Hooe,Morgan).12-15
[Pottle,Brooke] Attack error by Walter,Chelsey (block by McGlathery,Kayla; Zanders,Katelynn).13-15
13-16[Pottle,Brooke] Kill by Walter,Chelsey (from Williams,Kyndal).
MSUB subs: Grimsrud,Monica; Kirk,Kimmy.
[Norris,Krista] Kill by McGlathery,Kayla (from Hooe,Morgan).14-16
UAA subs: McInerney,Caitlin; McGlathery,Kayla.
[Barker,Quinn] Attack error by Norris,Krista.15-16
[Barker,Quinn] Attack error by Williams,Kyndal (block by McInerney,Caitlin).16-16
16-17[Barker,Quinn] Kill by Walter,Chelsey (from Williams,Kyndal).
MSUB subs: Gentili,Alaina; Wells,Haley.
[Walter,Chelsey] Kill by Zanders,Katelynn (from Hooe,Morgan).17-17
[Hooe,Morgan] Kill by Zanders,Katelynn (from Hooe,Morgan).18-17
[Hooe,Morgan] Kill by Mackey,Julia (from Hooe,Morgan).19-17
19-18[Hooe,Morgan] Kill by Grimsrud,Monica (from Williams,Kyndal).
MSUB subs: Ward,Ashlynn; Roderick,Mataia.
[Williams,Kyndal] Kill by Zanders,Katelynn (from Hooe,Morgan).20-18
20-19[Zanders,Katelynn] Kill by Gentili,Alaina (from Williams,Kyndal).
[Grimsrud,Monica] Kill by Pottle,Brooke (from Hooe,Morgan).21-19
UAA subs: Johnson,Sarah; McInerney,Caitlin.
MSUB subs: Kirk,Kimmy; Grimsrud,Monica.
[Johnson,Sarah] Bad set by Wells,Haley.22-19
[Johnson,Sarah] Kill by Pottle,Brooke (from Mackey,Julia).23-19
23-20[Johnson,Sarah] Service error.
MSUB subs: Walter,Chelsey; Gentili,Alaina.
UAA subs: Barker,Quinn; Johnson,Sarah.
23-21[Wells,Haley] Kill by Norris,Krista (from Williams,Kyndal).
[Wells,Haley] Kill by Mackey,Julia (from Hooe,Morgan).24-21
24-22[Mackey,Julia] Kill by Walter,Chelsey (from Williams,Kyndal).
MSUB subs: Roderick,Mataia; Ward,Ashlynn.
24-23[Roderick,Mataia] Attack error by Pottle,Brooke.
[Roderick,Mataia] Attack error by Walter,Chelsey.25-23